Question Solved

How do I manage references in LaTeX.BibTeX, BibLaTeX, or Zotero?

Back to Forum
Starting 40 pts 0 followers
JSS Academy of Higher Education and Research · Posted

Situation

I completed my MTech from NIT Trichy in 2022 and have been working in industry since then. I now want to apply for PhD programs, both in India (IISc, IITs) and abroad (ETH, CMU, UW).

My concern

Does a two-year industry gap hurt PhD applications significantly? I have:

  • 1 workshop paper at NeurIPS 2023
  • 2 patents filed (1 granted)
  • Good academic record (9.1 CGPA)
  • Strong recommendation letters from my MTech guide

Would love to hear from people who have successfully navigated this situation.

Sign in to join the discussion.

3 Replies

0
Gopal Naidu · Accepted answer

I think you are conflating two separate problems here. The publish-or-perish culture creates pressure, yes.but the solution is not to criticize researchers who are navigating an unfair system. The real problem is with evaluation committees who treat publication count as a proxy for research quality. Fix the evaluation, and the incentives change.

Also worth noting: open review has been implemented in some fields and has its own problems. It can disadvantage early-career researchers who fear retaliation from senior colleagues they have reviewed critically.

0
Sanjay Kumar Growing 145 pts · Accepted answer

Respectfully, I think this framing misses the systemic dimension. Individual researchers cannot solve a collective action problem. If you submit to open-access journals and your colleague submits to Nature, your colleague gets the promotion. Until evaluation criteria change at the institutional level.which requires policy intervention.individual choices have minimal impact.

0
Hema Suresh Starting 20 pts · Accepted answer

The ethics review situation in Indian universities is actually more complex than most people realize.

There is no uniform national framework equivalent to the US Common Rule. Each institution has its own Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC) or Institutional Review Board (IRB).

For anonymous survey research with no identifiable data and no vulnerable populations: most Indian IECs would classify this as exempt, but 'exempt' still needs a formal determination from the IEC.it is not self-certifying.

My practical advice: go to your institution's research ethics office now, describe what you did, and request an exempt determination in writing. Better to have documentation than to discover the issue during thesis review.